☆Rory☆ (kamitatsubane) wrote in ed_ucate,
☆Rory☆
kamitatsubane
ed_ucate

Photoshopping Healthier Bodies? (cont'd)

There was previously an article posted on this subject, and discussion was left open. The thread can be found here.

Few comments were made, but most seemed to be those of disbelief. "Why on earth would someone photoshop a model to make her look fatter?" No one said those particular words, but don't deny it -- a lot of you are thinking it.

Well, for those of you who wanted to see some proof, I've decided to provide a demonstration. It's very difficult to find raw photos from model photoshoot, so runway is the next best thing. Here are a few raw photos I've edited with comparison to obviously edited magazine photos. Curious? Then check 'em out!

(Model : Vlada Roslyakova)
Demonstration #1 - Chest

Before Edit
before

After Edit
after

Raw Photo
raw

Lighting / Professional Editing
edit

Tricky Lighting
edit

Demonstration #2 - Shoulder

Before Edit
before

After Edit
after

Magazine Photo
edit

Demonstration #3 - Overall Shape

Angling, Lighting, and Editing
edit


Obviously, there has been some editing of Vlada's photographs to make her chest and shoulders appear less bony. And don't even get me started on her legs! (I didn't have time for those.) One could argue that it's simply the lighting which makes her appear less bony, but let me point out that its the professional photographers who actively choose to have her pose and the lights shown on her in a particular way to make her more aesthetically pleasing (i.e. less bony) before editing. The better a model looks in her raw photo, the better she'll look in the edited version.

Now that I believe I've thoroughly presented my case, I'd like to ask what ya'll think about this.

Discussion: Editing photos to make models appear less skinny -- is it right? Think about the consequences concerning mental and physical health, that of the model's and the average consumer's. Also, what's worse -- editing photos to make "fat" people appear healthier, or "skinny" people to appear healthier?

I know one thing for sure -- all these photos of celebrities with perfect skin make me self-conscious about every single blemish!
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

  • 16 comments